How to Choose a Facilitator: What to Look For and the Questions That Sort Them

In short
- To choose a facilitator, judge the design they would run for your brief, not how impressive they are in the interview.
- Ask each candidate for a session outline, how they handle a senior person who dominates, and what you receive afterwards.
- Score three proposals on one weighted grid, with the weights fixed before you open any of them.
- A trainer’s proposal starts with their course. A facilitator’s starts with your group’s decision.
- I lead conference days. I have led only a handful of workshops of 100 or more, and I do not supply strategy or subject content.
How to choose a facilitator is a question of design, not charisma. A facilitator is a neutral guide who designs and runs how a group works together, so the evidence you want is the plan they would run for your brief and what they would do about the person who talks most.
Below: what to judge, four questions that sort candidates, a grid for comparing proposals, and what a good brief contains.

How to choose facilitator candidates: what should you judge?
Judge a facilitator on the session design they propose for your brief, because that is the part of the job you can see before you pay. The International Association of Facilitators lists six areas of core competency, and the first two, creating collaborative client relationships and planning appropriate group processes, are the two a proposal can show.
The Rockefeller Foundation’s guide to choosing a facilitator says an external professional brings neutrality, has no prior alliances in the room, and can dedicate preparation time to facilitation rather than splitting attention between content and production.
A confident interview tells you about the person. It does not tell you whether the 11am block will produce a decision. For the definition itself, see what facilitation is.
What should you ask each facilitator before you book?
Four questions sort candidates, because each can only be answered with a design, not a pitch.
| Ask | A good answer | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| What session plan would you run for my brief? | A timed outline where every block has a question, a method and an output | A menu of methods, or a template with your logo on it |
| What do you do when a senior person dominates? | A method agreed beforehand: a pre-brief, writing before speaking, a rule on who holds the floor | “I’m good with people” |
| What happens when the plan breaks? | A real example of changing the plan mid-session, and why | They have never had to |
| What will I have afterwards? | Decisions, owners and dates, with a delivery date | Photographs of flip charts |
SessionLab, a facilitation software company, also suggests asking how a facilitator has adapted when things did not go as planned (read November 2026).
Why press on domination? An MIT-led study in Science, published in September 2010, found that groups where one person dominated were less collectively intelligent than groups sharing turns. The NHS Institute’s guide to facilitation (2010) puts domination by a few individuals first in its list of signs that group work is not working.
My own answer is one tool, not a method. At a conference I hold on to the microphone: as long as I have not handed it over, I keep control, and if I do hand it over I end up politely wrestling it back. Yours should have more than one tool.
How to choose facilitator proposals: scoring three side by side
Score every proposal against the same weighted criteria, and fix the weights before you open any of them. Government guidance for public buyers under the Procurement Act 2023, read November 2026, says the assessment method and the relative importance of the criteria must be set out in advance, and that weightings can be percentages. You are not bound by it. It does stop a charming interview rewriting the maths.
These weights are my suggestion, not a standard. Score each criterion from 0 to 5.
| Criterion | Weight | What a 5 looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Fit of the plan to your brief | 30 | Timed blocks tied to your decisions |
| Handling dominant voices and conflict | 20 | A named method, agreed with the sponsor |
| Preparation before the day | 15 | Calls with you and some of the group |
| What you get afterwards | 15 | Decisions, owners, dates, on a stated day |
| Evidence | 10 | A reference you can phone from a similar brief |
| Clarity of the fee | 10 | States whether preparation, materials, travel and follow-up are included |
A worked example, with invented scores. Proposal A scores 4, 3, 4, 5, 3 and 4, multiplied by the weights: 385 out of 500. B scores 5, 2, 3, 3, 5 and 3: 360. C scores 3, 4, 5, 4, 4 and 5: 395. B has the best plan and the best references, but a weak answer on dominance puts it last.
If you have a budget ceiling, treat it as pass or fail before scoring, not as a score.
How can you tell a facilitator from a trainer selling a course?
A facilitator’s proposal is built around your group’s decision, and a trainer’s is built around their own content. SessionLab says a facilitator is not called in to provide training content or push an agenda, and the role is to design and guide the process.
Signs you are reading a course:
- Module titles arrive before anyone has asked who is in the room.
- The deliverable is slides and handouts.
- Learning outcomes stand where your decisions should be.
- The same programme is offered whatever you say.
A trainer is the right hire when the group lacks a skill. Ask for a facilitator when it lacks agreement.
Do certifications and references matter?
They help, but neither replaces the plan. The IAF’s Certified Professional Facilitator award is a live assessment against the six competencies: a role-played client conversation, two interviews and an observed 30-minute facilitation, valid for four years (IAF, read November 2026). It is a real signal. Plenty of capable facilitators do not hold it, so treat its absence as a question, not a verdict.
Ask for a reference from a client with a brief like yours, and phone them. SessionLab calls referral the most common route to a good facilitator. Ask me too: my clients’ words are on my reviews page.
What a facilitator brief contains
A brief tells the facilitator the purpose, the decisions needed, who is in the room and what is fixed, in a page or less.
- Date, venue, finish time and headcount.
- The purpose in one sentence.
- The two or three decisions or outputs the day must produce.
- Who attends, and who has the power to decide.
- What is off the table.
- What went wrong last time.
- What you want afterwards, and by when.
A Northern Ireland health and social care guide (June 2019) says the organiser should send a briefing and agenda before the session and name who records it. SessionLab advises drawing a facilitator in before the agenda is set, since a minute-by-minute agenda leaves little room to make anything participatory. If you already have one, the workshop agenda template shows where the breathing space goes.
When is it worth hiring one, and where do I fit?
Hire an outside facilitator when whoever would run the session has a stake in the answer or cannot chair and take part at once. The Rockefeller guide lists the case for a subject expert in the chair: subject-specific questions, less preparation, no extra fee. That is the do-it-yourself case, and for a routine session it is often right.
I am Kevin Durham, a broadcast-trained conference host, MC, panel moderator and facilitator. As a conference facilitator I can collect delegates’ questions in RoomReader, my own software, before the event, and run dot voting on the day. I do not supply strategy or subject content, and a workshop of 100 or more is something I have led only a handful of times, so score me on the grid like everyone else.
Send the brief above to hello@conferencehost.uk, or ring 07596 851647, to check availability. Each booking is quoted per event as a fixed price with no hidden extras, as part of my work as a conference host.
17:00Close
Send me your agenda. I’ll show you where the room comes alive.
A fixed price, a free planning call, and a reply within one working day.


